The Gloves are off for change to the selection system

Peak Performance Coach

With the exit of former Australian Test gloveman, Rod Marsh as chairman of the Australian selection panel, it is a very appropriate time to consider new options for the national selection system.

While I am not close to Australian cricket as I once was, I do hear from time to time from people who are. Players, coaches and high performance say that change is needed.

I know from my time as a head coach, I found one of the biggest interferences to running the team and developing team culture was the clutter of voices who were authorised to talk to players on critical matters, such as selection or non-selection.

I had no personal problem with any of these very decent and well-credentialed gentlemen. It was simply they were not in and around the team, except for short periods. And so their decisions, either spoken publicly with team announcements, in private conversations by phone, or no conversation at all leaving an athlete bewildered, caused unnecessary tensions, conflicts and obstacles to team development.

Consequently, I see now is the chance to lead the game by challenging an age-old system that was formulated pre- coaches, pre-technology, pre- 3 game formats, pre-women’s cricket, pre-increased international schedules, and pre-high performance talent development approaches.

Cricket certainly lags behind other sports such as AFL, a number of Olympic sports and many of the franchised major sporting associations overseas such as EPL, NFL.


Like all talent and performance management systems in sport or business, the system needs to –

1.       Be totally aligned with the vision and future directions of the organisation; otherwise, individuals are hired or selected who cannot help drive the success of the team or the business;

2.       Provide the most accurate and efficient feedback communications to staff or athletes about their performance so that the individual can continually develop his or her game;

3.       Overcome methodologies which have bias towards certain types of individuals, such as those that promote or demote on age, or a limited skill set, or their marketability, or emotive or sentimental reasons


In order to do so, the sport, the business, or in this case the Australian cricket, requires satisfying two main pre-requisites:

I.            There is a clear vision for how Australian cricket wishes to play the game, across different formats, and for men and women.

II.            In order to chase this vision, and in the shortest time possible, there is an agreed set of Core Skills (technical, physical, mental, tactical, team, leadership) upon which all players in the talent development pathway, from entry level to international, are measured.


What does such a performance management system provide –

  • From a playing, coaching and sports science perspective, everyone becomes very clear on what demonstrated game skills an individual player is being measured against in order to put himself or herself in best position to be selected as an international player, and what to continue to do to retain selection;
  • Head coaches of international, national, domestic and youth programs become the key person to be responsible and accountable for running their respective programs;
  • With greater accountability and responsibility for a program, the head coach will ensure accountabilities across all athletes and staff within the program;
  • There will be greater collaboration between the programs to ensure easier transitions as an athlete moves into older age groups, or between formats of the game. The collaboration involves more open communication supported with technology;
  • An athlete’s performance plan can become a very real tool of assessing the progress, or otherwise of the individual, thereby having ramifications for selections and contracts


I do not think there will ever be the perfect selection system.


I began this process when Director of NZ Cricket. I removed all the selectors and setup a National Selection Manager position whose principal role was to create a robust information and data system that to aid the Head Coach select his or her teams. The system,

  • Took direction and advice from the National program head coach
  • Relied on the input of all Head Coaches of provincial teams
  • Utilised input of the High Performance Centre coaches
  • Used two impartial scouts, Martin Crowe and Glenn Turner for the men’s program


The advice and data received was based on players demonstrating core skill measures in game, as well as ‘gut instinct’ and intuition – akin to a combination of Michael Lewis’ “Moneyball” and Clint Eastwood’s 2012 movie “Trouble with the Curve”.

There is no doubt that the system met with resistance because it meant change.

Players did not think that they would be seen as they were used to selectors being at matches watching – even though coaches see them more regularly, and know where their games are at.

Coaches did not like the extra responsibility and accountability.

Captains felt that their status was being eroded, even though the Head Coach actively sought their views.

The Players’ Association did not like the change as it dramatically affected the contracting system.

And of course the selectors who were no longer on the payroll were in disagreement as well.

I would hope that at this juncture for cricket here in Australia, CA greets the New Year with brave and bold decision making around the game.

If it has this approach, then for me, the gloves are off when it comes to reviewing the current selection system.

Share This Post:

Get The First Chapter Of Our eBook For FREE!

Short description of the resource and explanation why it might be useful for one’s choice.

Related Posts

The Ashes

The Ashes

What Business can learn cricket. I was recently asked a series of questions about the significance of The Ashes. I coached the last Australian team to win in England in 2001. I coached a further 3 Ashes contests winning at home in 2003-04, losing a remarkable series in 2005, and…
Read Full Article
Art Skill Mindfulness

Leadership and the art or skill of Mindfulness

There have been plenty of articles written on this topic such as the one included by HBR – ARTICLE LINK The article discusses some of the work of Daniel Goleman, one of the great proponents of EI. The article also discusses the range of techniques to allow people especially busy…
Read Full Article


Here’s The Three Ways You Can Work
With Us To Achieve Better, Lasting Results.

A coach and a leader with a unique perspective on the world, John is at home in any environment which seeks change, a desire for peak performance, and a vision to be the world’s best.



Are you planning to reach your Everest…be at the top of your game like a world champion team? Master Coach and Strategist John Buchanan will give you the road map, the tools and the inspiration you need to reach your summit.



This world champion coaching model will provide you, your team and your business with a road map to the top and the sacrificial acts that world champion teams embrace to give the best chance of having a “PB day”, every day at work.

Online Programs

Online Programs

I will be building relevant, insightful, practical courses and modules which will help you as a Leader and/or Coach to quickly make changes to the way you lead your teams, and indeed, the teams you want to create.